Councillors unanimously deferred 90 homes on the old High Brooms gas works because none would be affordable. The plan goes back for talks with the developer.

Plans for up to 90 homes on the former gas works in Sandhurst Road, High Brooms, have been sent back for more work because none of them would be affordable housing. The borough council’s Planning Committee voted unanimously to defer the outline application on 21 October, against its officers’ advice to approve it.

The minutes of that meeting were published this week, ahead of the committee’s next meeting on 18 November. (Planning Committee draft minutes, 21 October 2026)

The application, reference 25/02259/OUT, is from J. Murphy & Sons Limited. It is not on the 18 November agenda. (Planning Committee, 18 November 2026: agenda)

Why councillors deferred it

The Local Plan allocates the site, under policy AL/RTW7, for 170 to 200 homes, 30% of them affordable. The application offered up to 90 homes and no affordable homes at all, on site or elsewhere. (Planning Committee report, 25/02259/OUT)

Instead, the developer offered a payment of £225,000 towards affordable housing elsewhere. Officers told the meeting this could rise to around £295,000 once a separate payment for the Pembury Road corridor is settled. The developer’s total offer across all its planning contributions was £950,000.

The council’s own housing team said the policy would expect 27 affordable homes on a scheme this size, 60% of them for social rent. It put the equivalent cash value of that at £3,454,003.

Bar chart comparing £3,454,003, the cash equivalent of policy-compliant affordable housing on the Gas Holder site in Sandhurst Road, with the £225,000 the applicant offered
The gap between the policy figure and the offer. Chart by Tunbridge Wells Today
Share this chartFacebookWhatsAppX

According to the minutes, councillors raised these points in the debate:

  • affordable housing is a fundamental part of the Local Plan and should not be compromised
  • £225,000 would not contribute meaningfully to the area
  • approving it would set an undesirable precedent for cutting affordable housing on viability grounds
  • 114 parking spaces, including visitor spaces, were not enough, a view the council’s Parking Services shared
  • the plan offered 225 square metres of children’s play space, against about 405 needed
  • the landscape buffer on the western edge was not adequate
  • some blocks sat close to the railway and to the areas at higher risk of flooding
  • South East Water had not formally responded to a major application

Councillor Pound proposed the deferral and Councillor Neville seconded it. Members said they supported building on the site in principle. They asked officers to go back to the developer on density, parking, tenure and community provision.

Why the developer says it cannot pay more

The site is contaminated, and part of it is in Environment Agency flood zones 2 and 3. Officers said an updated flood risk assessment shrank the area that can take housing, which is why the plan is for up to 90 homes rather than 170 to 200. Extra regulation for buildings over 18 metres also hit the figures.

Officers set out the viability figures at the meeting:

Scheme tested Developer profit
185 homes 2.2%
90 homes (the application) 12.1%

They said 80 homes would be the most profitable option. The 90-home scheme was put forward to get closer to the density the Local Plan expects. The expected profit on it is £3.857 million, after planning contributions.

The Environment Agency and Kent County Council both withdrew earlier objections after updated flood and drainage submissions, the report says.

What the plans include

The outline plan, with only the access fixed at this stage, shows:

  • 23 one-bedroom flats
  • 32 two-bedroom flats
  • 35 three-bedroom houses
  • two-storey terraces and blocks of flats of up to four storeys
  • a rerouted public footpath across the site
  • a drainage basin on the land not used for housing

A planning condition would limit water use in the new homes to 110 litres per person per day. The building regulations standard is 125 litres.

Other payments in the officers’ recommendation included £97,594 for NHS services within three miles and £106,214 for the Woodlands play area on Merrion Way.

The three gasholders on the site were demolished in 2013 and 2014. The council revoked the last hazardous substance consents for the land in June 2026.

The council received four representations on the application. Two objected, raising contamination, flood risk and the scale of the buildings. The Civic Society said any detailed scheme needed a radically different approach to parking, the footpath and flood risk.

What it means for you

  • If you live near Sandhurst Road: nothing is decided. The application stays live, and will come back to the Planning Committee once officers have talked to the developer. No date has been set.
  • If you are waiting for social housing: the committee has refused, for now, to accept a scheme with no affordable homes. Whether more can be squeezed out of the site is what the talks will decide.
  • Want to follow it? The application and every document on it are on the council’s planning register under 25/02259/OUT. Planning Committee meetings are webcast live on the council’s democracy pages.